Propagation by the Wise
Background
This letter was sent from Minobu to Shijō Kingo in the ninth month of 1276. Because Lord Ema disapproved of his retainer Shijō Kingo’s belief in the Daishonin’s teachings, he harassed Kingo in various ways. At one point he even threatened to transfer the samurai to the remote province of Echigo on the Sea of Japan if he refused to renounce his allegiance to the Daishonin. This letter was the Daishonin’s answer to Kingo’s request for guidance in these circumstances.
The letter clarifies the two necessary elements for the propagation of Buddhism: a person of wisdom and supporters to aid him.
Chapter1(Describing the Relationship between the Wise Person and the Lay Believer)
THE correct teaching of the time can be propagated only by a person of wisdom. This is why Shakyamuni Buddha, after expounding all the sutras, entrusted the Hinayana sutras to Ānanda and the Mahayana sutras to Manjushrī. Concerning the heart of the Lotus Sutra, however, the Buddha refused to transfer it to any of the voice-hearers [such as Ānanda] or to bodhisattvas such as Manjushrī. The Buddha instead summoned Bodhisattva Superior Practices and entrusted it to him.
Even if a person of wisdom who embraces the correct teaching existed, how could he propagate it without lay believers who supported him? Shakyamuni Buddha had the support of Brahmā and Shakra, who were his patrons in heaven. From among the six paths, the Buddha chose the worlds of human and heavenly beings, and of these two, he chose to be born among human beings. Of all the places in the major world system inhabited by human beings, he appeared in the center, the five regions of India, and within the five regions, in the kingdom of Magadha.
The king of this land should have been a patron of the Buddha, but instead the country’s ruler, King Ajātashatru, was an evil man. The most unfortunate destiny for a sage is to be born during the reign of an evil monarch. King Ajātashatru had murdered his father, a worthy ruler. Even worse, he had taken Devadatta as his mentor. Devadatta had committed three cardinal sins, the worst of which was injuring the Buddha and causing him to bleed. The unfilial and evil king joined forces with this blasphemous teacher, thus laying a double burden on the people.
Not only for one or two years but for several decades, this king repeatedly harassed the Buddha and killed countless numbers of his disciples. This infuriated the heavenly gods, and the skies reacted violently. Moreover, the earthly gods were so provoked that great disasters occurred on earth. Month after month violent gales raged, and year after year famines and epidemics struck, killing the majority of the people. Furthermore, neighboring kingdoms attacked on all sides, driving Magadha to the brink of ruin.
Then, motivated by a revelation in a dream, by the advice of Jīvaka and, finally, by his own inner doubts, King Ajātashatru left Devadatta and presented himself before the Buddha to repent of his sinful deeds. As a result, his illness was cured immediately, the invasions ceased, and the entire country became peaceful. Not only that, he was also able to thwart the prophecy that he would die on the seventh day of the third month and in fact prolonged his life by forty years. In gratitude, he assembled a thousand arhats to record all the Buddha’s teachings, especially the Lotus Sutra, for future generations. It is therefore owing to King Ajātashatru that we have the Lotus Sutra we embrace today.
Lecture
1. The Propagation of the Correct Law Depends on a Wise Person
No matter how great a Law may be, it cannot spread naturally on its own. This is equally true of the Mystic Law (Myoho). Without the right person to advocate for it, the Law would remain buried. Therefore, the Daishonin teaches: “The Law does not spread by itself. Because people spread it, both the person and the Law are worthy of respect” (GoshoZenshuu, p. 856), and ” All the various teachings of the Buddha are spread by persons.” (WND-1, Questions and Answers about Embracing the Lotus Sutra, p. 61).
The person who spreads the Correct Law must be a “wise person” (chijin). While the conditions for being a “wise person” can be discussed in many ways, the fundamental requirement here is to deeply and correctly understand and embody the Law that is meant to be spread in that specific era. This is why the Daishonin notes that different figures were designated for different teachings: Ananda for the Hinayana sutras, Manjushri for the Mahayana, and Bodhisattva Superior Practices (Jogyo) for the essence of the Lotus Sutra.
In the current era of the Latter Day of the Law, the “wise person” must be someone who correctly understands and embodies the Three Great Secret Laws. A practitioner of propagation must, first and foremost, be a person of wisdom who has internalized the philosophy of Buddhism. Based on this internalization, they must also be able to recognize the times, discern the capacity and thought of the people, and wisely and freely expound and implement the Law. This ability is defined by correctly discerning the “Five Guides for Propagation”: the teaching, the capacity of the people, the time, the country, and the sequence of propagation.
2. Though there be a Wise Person, How Can the Law Spread Without a Patron?
“Patron” (Danna) is translated as “almsgiver” or “benefactor”—one who supports the wise person materially and economically. Since those who preserve and propagate the Law are removed from secular production, they cannot provide for their own livelihood. Thus, they cannot survive without the support of those who respect and sustain them.
While the propagators depend on the patrons for material needs, they reciprocate by providing spiritual enrichment to society through the power of Buddhism. This is a principle of “division of labor,” a system by which not only religion but also art, politics, and science have been maintained and developed throughout history.
However, from the perspective of actively “spreading” Buddhism, the mission of the patron must be viewed more broadly. A patron who lives in secular society yet deeply understands Buddhism serves as the vital “pivot” (kaname) for reflecting and implementing Buddhist values in the real world. For Buddhism to become a Law for all people rather than the exclusive domain of monks, the patron must be an active practitioner who works for social prosperity and human happiness, rooted in the Law.
In Shakyamuni’s Buddhism, the primary practitioners were monks, while kings and wealthy donors provided “outer protection” as patrons. Most of his sutras were addressed to disciples who had renounced the world. In contrast, almost all of Nichiren Daishonin’s writings were addressed to secular laypeople. Even the Gohonzon, the purpose of his advent, was inscribed for lay practitioners as petitioners. This clearly illustrates the socially engaged nature of Nichiren Daishonin’s Buddhism.
3. The Two Misfortunes of Human Society
The Daishonin writes that the greatest disasters for humanity occur when a ruler—the decider of secular society—is an “evil king” who has failed as a human being, and when the religious leaders who define spiritual foundations are “slandering teachers” who destroy the Correct Law.
An “unfilial evil king” refers to someone who lacks even the most basic human quality: repaying debts of gratitude (ho-on) to the parents who gave them life. In a monarchical system, the ruler’s will decided the fate of society; thus, an “evil king” was the root of social suffering. In a modern democracy, this “king” corresponds to society itself.
Human beings do not live by material things alone. Our happiness is not determined solely by external factors. In fact, internal, spiritual factors carry even more weight. These internal factors are determined by one’s philosophy and religion. From the perspective of the three existences of life (past, present, and future), material and external factors are limited to this lifetime, whereas spiritual and internal factors span across the future.
This is why the Daishonin states that the meeting of an “unfilial evil king” and a “slandering teacher” constitutes the “two misfortunes of humanity.” This passage clearly presents the two essential pillars—political/social integrity and spiritual/religious truth—that are indispensable for a healthy human society.
Chapter2(Revealing the Wise Person of the Latter Day of the Law)
But let us set aside the story of Ajātashatru. If I were to repeat the teachings given by the Buddha to King Ajātashatru, the Japanese would consider them to be merely my own fabrications. But since you are my disciple and supporter, I will reveal them to you. The Buddha states: “After my death, in the Latter Day of the Law, the land will be filled with those who pretend to be pious by observing the five ascetic practices1 as Devadatta did. They will persuade an evil ruler to act against the one person of wisdom. They will curse or strike him, cause him to be exiled, and even make an attempt on his life. At that time there will be ominous changes in the heavens and strange occurrences on earth, as well as violent winds, famines, and epidemics greater than ever witnessed before, and these disasters will continue year after year. The land will be attacked by another country.” This is the substance of the tenth volume of the Protection Sutra.
The present age has developed exactly as the Buddha predicted it would, and Nichiren may be the person of wisdom whom the Buddha described. Though some people wish to help me, either their determination is weak, or, though firmly resolved, they are unable to act on their intentions. Thus, you are one of the very few whose actions match their will. You surpass others in your resolve, and it is because of your devoted support that I have been able to survive. The heavens are certainly aware of this; the earth surely knows about it, too. If any misfortune were to occur to you, it could only mean that heaven wanted my life itself. Wherever one may be, whether in the mountains, on the seas, in the skies, or in the cities, one cannot escape death. Nevertheless, a sutra explains that even one’s fixed karma can be changed.2 T’ien-t’ai’s commentary also states that one can prolong one’s fixed span of life.
As I have advised you before, until the Mongol forces actually attack this country, continue to conduct yourself in a circumspect manner.
Notes
1. The five ascetic practices refer to the five precepts expounded in Hinayana Buddhism: to wear discarded ragged clothes, to seek alms, to have only one meal a day, to remain out of doors always, and to avoid sweet, sour, bitter, spicy, and salty food.
2. This statement is adopted from a passage in The Annotations on “The Words and Phrases of the Lotus Sutra.” Karma is the potential force inherent in one’s life that influences one’s future. Fixed karma means a span of life fixed by karma. The reference in the next sentence to T’ien-t’ai’s commentary indicates Great Concentration and Insight.
Lecture
In the previous section, it was revealed that Buddhism cannot spread without the cooperation of a “Wise Person” and a “Patron.” Building upon this, the current section provides powerful encouragement, stating that in the Latter Day of the Law, Nichiren Daishonin is that very “Wise Person,” and Shijo Kingo is the exceptional patron who assists him. Consequently, it is inconceivable that the protective heavenly deities—the guardians of Buddhism—would fail to protect Kingo.
Shijo Kingo was a prominent believer who stood at the forefront of the practitioners in Kamakura. He was a devoted follower who never ceased sending offerings to the Daishonin, both during the harsh exile to Sado Island and after the Daishonin entered Mount Minobu. The Daishonin credits Shijo Kingo for the fact that he has been able to survive to this day. He expresses his profound conviction and boundless compassion by stating that any harm befalling Shijo Kingo would be the same as ending the Daishonin’s own life.
Changing the Unchangeable: The Principle of “Fixed Karma”
“Wherever one may be, whether in the mountains, on the seas, in the skies, or in the cities, one cannot escape death. Nevertheless, a sutra explains that even one’s fixed karma can be changed.“
Fixed Karma (Jogyo) vs. Unfixed Karma (Fujogyo)
-
Fixed Karma (Jogyo): This refers to karma predetermined by past causes that necessitates a specific result or retribution. Whether good or bad, it is “fixed” when the past causes were strong enough to make the resulting effect certain.
-
Unfixed Karma (Fujogyo): This refers to karma where the direction is only loosely set; it is weak enough to be changed through one’s caution, attitude, and efforts in this lifetime.
The Three Causes of Fixed Karma
Fixed karma is said to be created through three types of actions:
-
Habitual Actions: Deeds repeated so often they become deeply ingrained.
-
Acts of Pure Intent: Actions performed with a sincere and profound heart.
-
Prayer to the Three Treasures: Acts related to the Buddha, the Law, and the Priest.
These causes are etched deeply into one’s life and strongly dictate the future. Once karma becomes “fixed,” it is traditionally believed that one cannot escape it, no matter where one hides—be it in the mountains, the sea, the sky, or the city.
The Principle of Changing Destiny (Shukumei Tenkan)
Conversely, the Daishonin teaches that no matter what kind of fixed karma one has created in the past, if one offers powerful prayers to the Three Treasures (the Correct Law) in the present, practices with a pure heart, and maintains the consistency of Faith, Practice, and Study, one can transform even the worst fixed karma. By doing so, one establishes the “supreme fixed karma” toward attaining Buddhahood. This is the fundamental principle of transforming one’s destiny through the correct practice of Buddhism.
Chapter3(Instructing the Response to One’s Lord)
As for the reply to your lord, declare to him firmly: “Since I am ill, it is most distressing for me to be transferred to a remote place. Moreover, the entire country is already in turmoil. Should an emergency arise, how could I possibly be a coward? At this moment I am resolved to sacrifice my life for my lord if anything grave happens. But should a sudden crisis occur, it is doubtful whether I could reach you in time from the distant province of Echigo. Therefore, even at the risk of losing my estate, I will not leave you this year. Anything else you command of me, I will obey without hesitation or fear. Even more important to me than this, however, are the priest Nichiren and my deceased parents.”
Say in a ringing voice, “Even if you disown me, I will devote my life to you. My next life I have entrusted to the priest Nichiren.”
Nichiren
The sixth day of the ninth month in the second year of Kenji (1276), cyclical sign hinoe-ne
To Shijō Kingo
Lecture
This section provides meticulous instructions on how Kingo should respond to his lord, Ema. However, its significance extends far beyond mere tactics; from this passage, we must learn the fundamental attitude that a practitioner should hold toward both their faith and society.
Transcending Feudal Ethics
First, the Daishonin emphasizes that as a member of society, one must fulfill one’s social responsibilities to the very end. He clearly demonstrates that this commitment is something to be upheld even if it requires defying a lord’s unreasonable command. From this, we can discern that the ethics the Daishonin envisioned for a citizen transcended the narrow, specialized ethics of the feudal master-servant relationship.
Universal Human Morality
Second is the fundamental human concern expressed in the sentence: “Even more important to me than this, however, are the priest Nichiren and my deceased parents.“ The “matter of parents” represents universal human ethics—a moral obligation that must never be violated, even at the command of a sovereign. This concerns the very foundation of one’s existence as a human being. Such universal morality takes precedence over the circumstantial loyalty one owes to a lord.
Spiritual Freedom and the Three Existences
Furthermore, the “matter of the priest Nichiren” refers to one’s own religious convictions and the practice of the Buddhist Law. By extension, this represents the realm of spiritual freedom for a self-aware individual. This, too, takes precedence over social loyalty. While social loyalty can only influence one’s material well-being in this present life, the Buddhist Law concerns the happiness and suffering of life throughout the three existences of past, present, and future.
Therefore, while a Kamakura samurai may dedicate his physical life in this world to his lord, regarding the afterworld, the Daishonin instructs Kingo: “Say in a ringing voice, “Even if you disown me, I will devote my life to you. My next life I have entrusted to the priest Nichiren.”“